Comments for Twilight Lexicon

Comment on The Poll That Asks All The Questions by NewJacob

NewJacob — Wed, 17 Dec 2008 06:56:22 +0000

Please cast someone else!!!!! Steph wants STEVEN STRAIT, and so do I!

Comment on The Poll That Asks All The Questions by Heart Song

Heart Song — Wed, 17 Dec 2008 06:31:41 +0000

The likelihood of finding an actor who is 6′5″ and can portray Jacob is not not very high. There just aren’t that many men who are that tall to begin with. A compromise will be made regardless of who is cast.
KEEP TAYLOR, HE WAS GREAT.
If they can make grown men look like hobbits and dwarves, surely they can make Taylor appear taller if they want to. Frankly, I don’t see the height thing to be that critical to the story given the other changes that are sure to occur as the story is adapted for the big screen. Maintaining the integrity of the character is FAR more important.

Comment on Movie News by Sare

Sare — Wed, 17 Dec 2008 06:09:42 +0000

I just think that Peter and his family are so cute.

Comment on The Poll That Asks All The Questions by whocares?

whocares? — Wed, 17 Dec 2008 06:03:05 +0000

Who cares? No one can pull off that nasty long hair anyway. Im 20 and I don’t think jacob should be as tall as me,I’m 5′9. he’s like 6′5 in the book so unless he hits a growth spurt, cast someone else.

Comment on Movie and Cast News by Sare

Sare — Wed, 17 Dec 2008 05:55:01 +0000

Aww, I think Nikki looks pretty!

Comment on The Poll That Asks All The Questions by R Cullen (for edward only)

R Cullen (for edward only) — Wed, 17 Dec 2008 05:44:51 +0000

OMG…..dont change Tayloor plz…he playz Jacob really good …..plz dont change him or else….i wil not watch th movies full stop. plzzzzzz
i lik taylor as jacob soooo pls Sumit….dont break ma bubble………DONT DO IT OR ELSE……

Comment on The Poll That Asks All The Questions by Confusion

Confusion — Wed, 17 Dec 2008 05:39:43 +0000

IF Taylor really WAS PERFECT for the role of older Jacob in N.M then they wouldnt be trying to think of all these ways to CHANGE his look for the part.
THAT is not rocket science.
To me I will be more bummed if Jacob doesnt have somewhat of fairly dramatic change. Mayne Taylor could pull it off. I dont know,I think I would have to wait for the actual movie to see. If he ould that would be pretty cool.But if it is NOT beleivable and he just ends up looking like a 16 year old that pumped up ALOT over the summer, I will be pissed. I just want him to look quite a bit larger that Edward, and at least 22 or somthing. I can lice withough him being 6′7..I just wish his facial featurs could look a bit older. I Wish Taylor could age faster darnit. But i dont think he could look old enough even 3 years from now and would rather them spend the money elswhere Like the wolves transformation and not Taylors to make him look older and somewhat taller.UGH I dont know. If they have to choose a new Jacob He better Be GOOD though. But I will wait and judge after i see abit of what they decide to do.

Comment on The Poll That Asks All The Questions by Dahlia

Dahlia — Wed, 17 Dec 2008 05:32:12 +0000

The character of Jacob will have to undergo a great deal of CGI anyway no matter who plays him, so they might as well keep him and “grow” him using CGI. Taylor did a great job playing Jacob and you really sensed the chemistry between him and Kristen Stewart. Don’t mess with that, Summit!

Comment on The Poll That Asks All The Questions by amor

amor — Wed, 17 Dec 2008 05:30:48 +0000

The Reason WHY Kristen hasnt read the ALL the series is because she said she wanted to concentrate on eaach story at a time and focus on that particular one and experience it with surprises THE WAY BELLA DOES. I think that is AWESOME! She did read Twilight before she made the movie and I am SURE she will be readin N.M next. I bet she has already started.
I think Kristen did AMAZING as the role for Bella. Not enough Emotion? what do you want her all hyper active and constanly groveling over Edward? PLUS..ITS FUNNY cause i saw an interview with Stephenie Meyer where she said the Kristens voice is how she imagined it in her head.
My husband even said that he thought Rob was really good as Edward but then said that he thought Kristen did better as Bella though! OH and he said Taylor needs to go.

Comment on The Poll That Asks All The Questions by Ephrain

Ephrain — Wed, 17 Dec 2008 05:25:48 +0000

It has been proven that when a main character is recasted in a series the movies and the franchise crash and burn, the Dark Knight is a good example because the character was killed off anyway and plus richard harris died when portraying dumbledore and people have been critical of gambon’s portrayal for years, but of course HP has continuity with its main charaters. This isn’t rocket science…keep the original cast, it’s not going to kill the plot, the outcome will still be the same.